Overthinking Football

Overthinking Football

Share this post

Overthinking Football
Overthinking Football
The Overthinking Football 23/24 Superlatives

The Overthinking Football 23/24 Superlatives

It's superlatives season here and the whole team have pulled together to hand out our Fantrax 2023/24 Fantasy season awards!

Christopher Adams's avatar
Andrew's avatar
Will's avatar
Gordon's avatar
Christopher Adams
,
Andrew
,
Will
, and
Gordon
Jun 12, 2024
∙ Paid

Share this post

Overthinking Football
Overthinking Football
The Overthinking Football 23/24 Superlatives
Share

The specifics seem a very long time age, so we’ll save incorrect early-season take amnesties for another time. Instead, I (Gordon) have once-again dragged the whole Overthinking Football crew in to talk awards. Specifically Fantrax awards. It’s time to recognize those contributors who’ve really made this Fantasy season memorable.

Like last year, we did what any self-respecting Fantrax publication would do: we drafted our Superlative categories. So each of us will be handing out three awards, before attempting to come to some agreement on this season’s Most Valuable Player (MVP).

So with no further ado… onto the awards!


Bargain of the season

Which player has delivered the most on their ADP value?

Image

This whole article is going to be rather boring if I give every award to Cole Palmer, so I’m going to place some artificial constraints on this particular superlative. Limiting it to players who were close to universally drafted (sorry, Anthony Gordon and Alfie Doughty), I have to shout out Pascal Gross for his stellar campaign. Gross is no stranger to Fantrax success, but still found himself with an ADP of 37 coming into the season. Not one to be outdone, he surpassed most of his big-name rivals, finishing the year 5th overall in WAR and ahead of the likes of Phil Foden, Trent Alexander-Arnold, and Martin Odegaard in xFpts. The Brighton man was simply fantastic, showing up nearly every match (82% Quality Starts), even when he was getting shuffled around positionally. We’ll see if De Zerbi’s exit from Brighton impacts Gross’s value moving forward, but the German has reminded everyone that he should be higher on draft boards next season.

-Andrew


The ‘Pete Maverick Mitchell, age is but a number award’ for best veteran performer of the year

Which player is defying logic to perform at a level well above their similarly aged peers?

Ever since Willian’s unceremonious departure from Arsenal in 2021 I assumed his fantasy career was finished, if not his global football relevance. When he surprisingly returned to Fulham for the 22/23 season, at the ripe age of 33, it felt like more of a curious footnote than a signing to make serious decisions around. This assumption was wrong, as Willian had a great fantasy season for an upstart Fulham side, netting 1.1 WAR across 25 starts, easily surpassing expectations. Could he catch lightning in a bottle again as a solid contributor to fantasy teams as an age 34 winger on a middling team? Turns out the answer was yes. While not as impressive as his previous year, he continued to provide good value at a low price, with a respectable tally of 9.45 xFpts per game and 0.62 WAR — a considerably better return than his age-34 peers — winning him the best veteran performer of the year award.

-Chris


The ‘Ke Huy Quan award’ for comeback player of the year

Which player has bounced back from a disappointing 2022?

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Overthinking Football to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Overthinking Football
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share